On Friday, November 20, City Hearings Officer approved PGE’s Harborton transmission project in Forest Park 

The decision approves removal of 393 trees (375 living, 18 dead), permanent fill of two wetlands, impacts to two streams, and 4.7 acres of natural resource disturbance in the park’s North Unit for a new 230 kV line into the Harborton substation (decision, pp. 3, 13-14).

This is the same project a unanimous City Council denied in May 2025. PGE appealed to the Land Use Board of Appeals, then asked for mediation. The City signed a settlement with PGE in July 2026; FPNA, Forest Park Conservancy, and Bird Alliance of Oregon were excluded from the final negotiations and did not sign. The three organizations issued a joint press release opposing the deal because it gives the public no clear oversight over how mitigation funds will be spent, directs City staff to write a favorable staff report, and falls short of the City’s own conservation goals for Forest Park.

Under the settlement, PGE pays the City $5.5 million in mitigation funds, $3.1 million more than the $2.4 million fee-in-lieu in its original application, plus $250,000 for a City consultant on future utility planning in the park. The decision makes both payments conditions of approval. The coalition had proposed dedicating at least $2 million more specifically to protecting and restoring land in the wildlife corridor north of the park, with oversight shared among the City and conservation partners. That proposal was not adopted. The agreement also preserves PGE’s ability to recover the mitigation payment from ratepayers through state or federal rate proceedings.

FPNA led the 2025 appeal and is a party to this case. We are raising funds to Defend Forest Park for legal counsel and appeal support activities.

What happens next

  • Appeal. Appeals to City Council are due by 4:30 PM on Friday, December 4. FPNA is appealing alongside our coalition partners.
  • Council hearing. The date is TBD, likely early 2027. On appeal, Council considers only evidence already in the hearing record (decision, p. 18).

Documents

Read the Hearings Officer’s decision (PDF; includes the City staff report)
Read the joint press release (PDF)
Read the coalition’s April 30 letter to the City and PGE (PDF)
City case page and documents

 

Ways to be involved

Join us at Skyline Grange on December 2nd for a community presentation 

Forest Park Neighborhood Association and Forest Park Conservancy will walk through what the City’s Hearings Officer decision means for Forest Park, what it approves, and the appeal to City Council. Bring your questions and a neighbor.

11275 NW Skyline Blvd, Portland, OR 97231 · The Grange’s main level is wheelchair accessible. 

Follow us on Instagram for daily case updates and calls to action

We will be posting daily updates about the case including how you can be involved and continue learning about its impacts. We’ll also share upcoming events hosted by us or by our coalition partners.

Give

Gifts fund FPNA’s attorney for the appeal. This is the one part of this work volunteers can’t do themselves.

  • Online: give on our Defend Forest Park page
  • Text: DEFENDFORESTPARK to 44-321
  • Check: payable to Forest Park Neighborhood Association, memo “Defend Forest Park,” mailed to Richard Kolbell, Treasurer, 1021 NW Skyline Blvd, Portland, OR 97229

FPNA is a 501(c)(3) Oregon nonprofit. Gifts are tax-deductible.

Your City Council

City Council will decide the appeal. Here’s who represents you.

District 4 (your representatives, Forest Park)
Councilor.Clark@portlandoregon.gov (Vice President Olivia Clark)
Councilor.Green@portlandoregon.gov (Mitch Green)
Councilor.Zimmerman@portlandoregon.gov (Eric Zimmerman)

District 1
Councilor.Avalos@portlandoregon.gov (Candace Avalos)
Councilor.Dunphy@portlandoregon.gov (Jamie Dunphy)
Councilor.Smith@portlandoregon.gov (Loretta Smith)

District 2
Councilor.Pirtle-Guiney@portlandoregon.gov (Council President Elana Pirtle-Guiney)
Councilor.Kanal@portlandoregon.gov (Sameer Kanal)
Councilor.Ryan@portlandoregon.gov (Dan Ryan)

District 3
Councilor.Koyamalane@portlandoregon.gov (Vice President Tiffany Koyama Lane)
Councilor.Morillo@portlandoregon.gov (Angelita Morillo)
Councilor.Novick@portlandoregon.gov (Steve Novick)

Case timeline

  • May 2024. PGE applies for the Harborton project (LU 24-041109).
  • March 2025. A City Hearings Officer approves the application. FPNA leads the appeal to City Council.
  • May 7, 2025. City Council denies the project 12-0.
  • 2025. PGE appeals to the Land Use Board of Appeals, then asks for mediation. Mediation between the City and PGE begins in fall 2025.
  • April 30, 2026. The coalition sends a mitigation proposal to the City and PGE. Letter (PDF)
  • July 2026. The City and PGE sign a settlement. FPNA, Forest Park Conservancy, and Bird Alliance of Oregon do not sign.
  • July 6, 2026. The three organizations issue a joint press release opposing the deal. Press release (PDF)
  • July 8, 2026. PGE refiles its application (LU 26-051203 CU EN GW).
  • October 2, 2026. City staff recommend approval.
  • October 14, 2026. Hearings Officer hearing. FPNA testifies.
  • November 4, 2026. The hearing record closes.
  • November 20, 2026. The Hearings Officer approves the project.
  • December 2, 2026. Community presentation, 7 PM, Skyline Grange.
  • December 4, 2026, 4:30 PM. Appeals to City Council due.
  • Early 2027 (TBD). City Council appeal hearing.

 

Where the Logging Happens

FPNA created this map to help neighbors see what PGE’s Phase 3 project would do to Forest Park’s North Unit. It assembles diagrams from PGE’s own land use application, PGE’s Arborist Tree Protection Plan and Exhibit E, which split the project area across several pages, and adds color, outlines, and a legend to show how the pieces fit together and what would be lost.

The blue line is the creek. The orange outlines mark the three small areas that would be protected from disturbance during construction. Trees inside those orange areas are generally left standing, though some would be topped. Everything outside them in the project area would be removed. The map is drawn from PGE’s September 2024 plans. PGE’s August 2026 tree plan changed the treatment of 38 trees, and the approved project removes 393 trees in all.

The long light-grey lines running alongside the protected areas are the two largest logging roads PGE proposes to build to move machinery into the site. The other grey shaded areas show where the ground would be graded, mostly around the towers and poles, along with staging areas.

Seen as a whole, the map shows how little forest would remain: three thin patches of protected trees surrounded by removal and new logging roads, cutting through habitat along the creek that connects the northern and southern parts of the park.

See the source documents. FPNA built this map from PGE’s own application exhibits. You can review the current versions in the City’s case file:

Base diagrams from PGE’s Phase 3 land use application (Exhibit E and Appendix B, Arborist Report). Map assembled and prepared by FPNA to illustrate the project’s impacts.

← Back to News